You’ve seen it every winter. A round bale goes in the ring feeder on Monday. By Thursday there’s a muddy ring of hay around it that no cow will touch. That trampled hay was bought, baled, hauled and stored. Then it went in the mud.
So does a vertical mixer pay off over bale feeders? Sometimes yes. Sometimes no. Here’s the no-fluff way to look at it.
Where hay waste comes from at a bale ring
Waste at a bale feeder comes from a few places:
- Cows pulling hay out and dropping it.
- Trampling and bedding down in loose hay.
- Spoilage on the outside of bales stored outdoors.
- Boss cows eating first and pushing the others out, so some hay goes stale before it’s eaten.
How much is lost depends a lot on the feeder design, bale quality and how many days a bale sits. Published university trials report a wide range. The point is that it’s rarely zero, and it adds up over a winter.
How a vertical mixer changes it
A vertical mixer cuts bales and blends them with other feeds. That changes a few things:
- Shorter, processed hay is harder to sort and pull out, so less ends up on the ground.
- You can stretch hay with cheaper feeds like straw, silage or byproducts, mixed so cows eat the whole ration.
- Every pen gets a weighed amount, so you’re not guessing.
But it’s not free. You’re running a tractor every day, and somebody has to load and feed.
Labour and diesel per day for each method
Bale feeding is simple. Move a bale every few days, cut the net, done. Low diesel, low labour per day.
Mixer feeding is a daily job. Load, mix, unload. That means:
- Tractor hours on the loader and the mixer.
- Diesel for both, every day.
- Labour, usually more than with bale rings.
- Maintenance on the mixer: knives, oil, wear parts.
To compare, put both on a per-day basis for your winter. Count the hay you buy or make, the waste you believe you’re losing, the fuel, the labour and the machine costs.
When the numbers favour a mixer
A mixer usually starts to make sense when:
- Hay is expensive or short, so every tonne you save counts.
- You have cheaper feeds you want to blend in.
- The herd is big enough to spread the cost over a lot of head.
- You want tighter control on condition, like heifers or cows coming into calving.
When they don’t
Bale feeders can still be the right call when:
- Hay is cheap and plentiful.
- The herd is small and labour is tight.
- You’re feeding for a short winter and the machine would sit most of the year.
Bottom line? It’s a numbers game on your own farm, not a rule.
Quick questions
How much hay can a mixer save? It varies with your current feeder, hay quality and how you feed. Measure your own waste over a few weeks if you can.
Can I feed whole bales through a vertical mixer? Yes. Vertical mixers are built to process round and square bales. Load them first and let them break down.
What about bale processors? They are another option. A mixer adds the ability to blend in other feeds.
Is a mixer worth it for a small herd? It can be, especially with expensive hay. Run the numbers first.
The short version
Bale rings are cheap to run but waste hay. A mixer saves hay and lets you blend feeds, but costs diesel, labour and upkeep. Put both on a per-day basis for your operation and let the numbers decide. If you want help working it out, talk to a LEO dealer or look through our VT twin auger feed mixers and the full LEO product line.
Learn more about LEO Agriculture and our full line of feed mixers and manure spreaders.
